Competitive distortion of musical pitch
Name(s):
Distortion of musical quality through escalating pitch
Nature
International standards of pitch in music are being violated under pressure for more brilliant and striking performances under conditions for which the music was not originally intended. The drift in pitch standards is also occurring to a different degree in different places even though professional musicians and singers travel frequently between them. The higher pitch transforms warm musical colour to garish. The whole spectrum of voice ranges has been twisted out of shape. The colour of the mezzo-soprano has disappeared and the basso profondo voice has disappeared.
Background
Pitch was arranged by the Greeks in descending and ascending ratios of seven different notes, currently denoted by the letters A through G. Prior to the 19th century, the note A could be as high or low as any particular culture favoured, varying as much as two tones. In the 19th century, with the increase in exchanges between cultures, efforts were made in Italy to impose the standard of A above middle C as being sound vibration at 432 cycles per second. For the past century a consensus has emerged, ratified in the 1930s by an international congress, that sets A at 440. Higher pitch has been compared to air pollution or toxic waste, where destruction results more from carelessness than calculation. Still higher pitch has its basis in the current economics of the arts. Concert halls are bigger in order to sell more seats. There is pressure on the organizers to attract attention with more "brilliant" performances whatever the loss in colour.
Incidence
Singers are now under pressure in opera and concert halls, especially in Italy, Austria and Germany, to adapt to a pitch which is now creeping above 445 toward 450, despite efforts to restandardize A at 440.
Claim
The increase in pitch from the classical C 256 to the norm of A 440 forces singers to change the notes at which voice register shifts occur. For the soprano a tuning at A 440 pushes the frequency of F beyond the dividing point between the first and second register. This arbitrary increase of pitch falsifies performance of all the musical classics.
Aggravated by
Strategy(ies)
Value(s)
Type
(F) Fuzzy exceptional problems