Problem

Refusal to provide medical treatment


Experimental visualization of narrower problems
Other Names:
Refusal to give medical care
Denial of access to prescription medication
Denial of prescription drugs
Nature:

Refusal to provide medical treatment can arise for a number of reasons, including financial and resource limitations. An increasing number of doctors and dentists are refusing to treat certain kinds of patients because of increased financial and physical risk. Particularly the risk of contracting AIDS and the risk of law suits for accidental death or disability are causing medical practitioners to select patients more carefully.

Governments cut out or ration ever more health services as costs rise. In Britain as of 1995, dental and optical services were no longer offered as part of the national health service. Elderly patients can be refused dialysis due to their age, because prolonging lives is not the best use of money after a certain age, according to the authorities who control the health services purse strings.

In other cases, physicians are wary of prescribing medication whose risks are equal or greater than the initial medical complication. Many argue it is the patient's right to decide which medical risks she should or should not take.

Incidence:

The British Medical Association has reported several cases in which patients had had their operations postponed or treatment withheld because they were committed smokers. By 1991, several British doctors refused to prescribe new thrombolytic drugs demonstrated to reduce risk of death in heart attack victims. Despite findings that the new medications were 25% more effective in death prevention, some doctors feared the drugs' slight risk of provoking internal bleeding and stroke. As a result, many heart patients and their families were outraged at medical denial of what seemed to be life-saving drugs.

Claim:

No one is forced to enter training for the life of a doctor, and patients have the right to expect treatment from their doctors when they are sick. Law suits are covered by medical insurance and its cost is passed on to patients. There is no reason for a doctor, dentist or nurse to refuse to treat a patient because of the disease unless it is outside the practitioners field of expertise.

Counter Claim:

The dishonesty among the pro-smoking lobby lies with their apparent assumption that smokers are somehow being punished by doctors who are refusing them treatment. Doctors are doing no such thing. If you have one heart and several patients needing a transplant, it is only natural that you give it to the patient most likely to survive the longest. Alcoholism, obesity, age and smoking are all pertinent factors.

Problem Type:
E: Emanations of other problems
Related UN Sustainable Development Goals:
GOAL 1: No PovertyGOAL 3: Good Health and Well-beingGOAL 16: Peace and Justice Strong Institutions
Date of last update
05.08.2019 – 21:52 CEST