Problem

Erosion of journalistic immunity

Other Names:
Denial of rights to journalists
Forced breach of journalistic confidence
Nature:

Pressure to make journalists reveal their sources of information may take the form of arrest, trial and imprisonment or general intimidation. Recent examples of threats to journalistic immunity have occurred in USA court cases, with convictions against journalists for the publication of the Pentagon Papers. In countries where political censorship is heavy, journalists may be imprisoned and tortured for subversive activities. Information may concern crime, corruption or other injustices, or be akin to espionage; and the possibility that sources would be revealed would risk making it more difficult or even impossible to obtain this information. The public would therefore be deprived of knowledge about matters which might concern them directly or indirectly.

Claim:

If democracy is an engine, a free press is the oil that makes it work. If journalists cannot protect their sources, those sources will dry up and with them the essential lubricant that makes the difference between an inert, formal structure and a mechanism that actually works. Legislation fails to recognize the importance of confidential journalistic sources to the health of the body politic.

 

Counter Claim:

Disclosure of journalistic sources is necessary when it is in the interests of justice or national security or for the prevention of disorder or crime.

Problem Type:
D: Detailed problems
Date of last update
19.06.2018 – 02:09 CEST
Web Page(s):