Problem

Secrecy


Experimental visualization of narrower problems
Other Names:
Dependence on secrecy
Secretive people
Cover up
Intentional concealment
Inadequate public disclosure
Secrets
Nature:
Concealment of information with the intention of preventing others from learning of it, possessing it, making use of it or revealing it to others. The keeping of secrets acts like a psychic poison, alienating their possessor from the community. Secrecy can debilitate judgement by preventing criticism thus reinforcing erroneous beliefs, lowering resistance to the irrational and the pathological. It allows people to maintain facades that conceal negative traits. Whenever there is a tendency to negligence or abuse, people and especially institutions, seek to surround themselves with ever greater secrecy, often without any real justification. Long-term group practices of secrecy are especially likely to breed corruption and to spread its effects.
Incidence:
Secrecy is widely practised by governments, especially with respect to questions touching on national security, which may be interpreted in the very broadest sense. Anti-terrorist groups, by their nature, practice extreme secrecy. Their accountability is very limited. It is suspected that classified information contains many facts which would be very disturbing to the general public if they were made readily available. Secrecy is also practised by most institutions to prevent their strategies from becoming known to other bodies which would hinder or take advantage of them.
Claim:
Secrecy means impropriety. Everything secret degenerates, even the administration of justice; nothing is safe that does not show how it can bear discussion and publicity.
Counter Claim:
Secrecy is necessary to prevent knowledge of the strengths and weaknesses of a society from being exposed to its potential enemies. In the case of the individual it is necessary to protect privacy, intimacy and any understanding of the sacred. Every individual, group and society has secrets. It is only when the maintenance of the secret impairs the creative functioning of another is it necessary to bring them into the open.
Reduced By:
Informers
Problem Type:
F: Fuzzy exceptional problems
Date of last update
01.01.2000 – 00:00 CET