Problem

Toxic waste smuggling

Other Names:
Illicit movement of toxic products
Export of toxic wastes
Covert trade in toxic wastes
Transboundary movement of hazardous wastes
Nature:

The industrialized countries are producing enormous quantities of toxic wastes and they do not have enough room to bury them. Disposal has been made even more difficult by pressures from environmental movements and by regulations. Furthermore, the cost of "clean" disposal of wastes, by high-temperature incineration is very high. The industrialized countries have therefore sought to get rid of their wastes on other continents and found out that sending them to developing countries was 10 times cheaper than other method. In the countries of destination, the local trading partners fell into the trap and it had thus been possible to offload substantial shipments.

Incidence:

In 1988, media coverage alerted the public to the uncontrolled dumping of million of tonnes of hazardous wastes across national borders, notably into Africa and east Europe. The management of wastes by such countries makes them even more hazardous, with practices such as long-term, unregulated storage on land and clandestine dumping into rivers and on the high seas being implicated. In 1994 declassified documents revealed that the UK government had illegally smuggled lethal radioactive debris from H-bomb tests in the Pacific back to the UK on scheduled flights from 1957; air crews were exposed to radiation does more than 30 times higher than the internationally agreed safety limit of the late 1950s when the first UK H-bombs were exploded.

Progressively tighter regulatory controls have increased the costs of waste disposal in many countries. Export to developing countries with less stringent controls and a lower public awareness of the issue has been one way in which some companies have side-stepped these regulations. Officially, fewer than 1,000 tonnes a year are traded to developing countries but illegal traffic in hazardous waste poses a potentially serious threat to the environment and human health (de Nava 1996).

Claim:

Irresponsible trade in hazardous waste is a disgrace. The developing countries should not be the dustbin of the industrialized world.

Counter Claim:

In 2002, 12 years after signing, the Basel Convention is not ratified by the USA.

Problem Type:
E: Emanations of other problems
Related UN Sustainable Development Goals:
GOAL 7: Affordable and Clean EnergyGOAL 12: Responsible Consumption and ProductionGOAL 16: Peace and Justice Strong Institutions
Date of last update
06.05.2019 – 20:33 CEST