Problem

Antisemitism

Other Names:
Discrimination against Jews
Anti-Semitic views
Anti-Zionism
Active prejudice towards Jewish people
Nature:
Antisemitism consists of hostile expressions or actions directed against the interests, legal rights, religious practices, or lives of Jews. It has has been a more or less constant feature of Jewish life since the Diaspora. The term was coined by Ernest Renan or Wilhelm Marr in the 1970s. It connoted the new form of Jew-baiting generated during the era of Jewish emancipation, which stressed racial and socio-economic antagonisms above the religious issues which earlier had dominated Jewish-gentile controversies.

Canaanites, Philistines, Babylonians, Assyrians, Greeks and Romans all fought the ancient Jews, and no doubt hated them, yet this did not make antisemitism a meaningful issue in those days. Nevertheless, the heritage of ancient and mediaeval hostilities remains. Even now it is argued that a single category of antisemitism is inadequate to describe anti-Jewish sentiment. In Europe, Jews were generally negatively seen as powerful, while in the Middle East they were historically perceived as weak. The empowerment of the Jews after 1948 may have inclined Arab views closer to the traditional European stereotype.

There is also the problem of distinguishing between antisemitism, a hatred of Jews and a desire to do them harm, and anti-Zionism, opposition to Israel's existence and security. Since the vast majority of Jews supports Israel's existence and security, opposition to Israel strikes directly and personally at one-third of all Jews and indirectly at the other two-thirds related to that country by sentiment or family ties. Consequently, there is a real overlap between the two categories of antisemitism and anti-Zionism. The dilemma of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), has been to find ways to delegitimize Israel while not being discredited in the West as antisemitic. This has partly been done by calling Zionism a distortion of Judaism, which is then defined only as a religion. The state of Israel itself is portrayed as a creation of Western imperialism rather than a nationalistic expression of the Jews.

Background:
Anti-Jewish hostility existed in ancient Alexandria where local tensions led to the propagation of many anti-Jewish slander and was concomitant of ancient ethnocentrism with its conviction of Greek and later Roman superiority. Antisemitism in the church and as a religious reality has its roots in the earliest teachings of the Church fathers, Epiphanius and Origen. To them the Jews were guilty of deicide, or treachery, and of failure to recognize the Messiah. Christians appeared to Jews as heretics, and Jews appeared to Christians as recalcitrant unbelievers. As Christianity grew in numbers and power, Christians subjected Jews to many forms of discrimination, sometimes to outright persecution with fratricidal fury. In the Middle Ages the Jews in Europe were generally consigned to ghettos and regarded as aliens within the feudal order.

The early religious intolerance by Christian communities, affected by cultural conflict and national self-preservation, was exacerbated in the 19th and 20th centuries by a fear of modernization and a hostility to capitalism. Different groups with a wide variety of concerns directed their antagonism against Jewish people, drawing on various stereotypes propagated in anti-Jewish campaigns. Until the 1870s, however, this was not cast in terms of race. The very concept of anti-Semitism was not used. Influenced by the race theories which came fully into the open around 1850, a major change took place during the last decades of the 19th century. The race theories of Comte Gobineau, which for the first time made use of the notion of the Aryan race, was reinforced by social Darwinism, and further cultivated among other places in the Bayreuth circle around Richard Wagner. It was finally translated through ideological writing into action by authors like Houston Chamberlin, who contributed to a consolidation of several strands of anti-Jewish sentiment which by 1870 was defined as anti-Semitism, building on vague assumptions of a biological heritage.

Semantic and intellectual confusion was extensive, to a large extent deliberately so. The notion of anti-Semitism builds on "semitic", which either can refer to language and culture or else to "the descendents of Shem" (derived from the description in the Biblical Genesis, Chapter X). Those two elements do not coincide, but for racists this is not of importance. Assumptions about biological descent, language, culture, social position, and the fear of carriers of modernization which allegedly destroyed national culture and the nation itself -- all of these elements were woven together. Small anti-Semitic political parties emerged in Germany during the end of the 19th century. In France, anti-Semitic sentiment culminated with the Dreyfus affair. By World War I these emotions had to a large extent been diffused, but in Germany the impact of the defeat during the war, together with the subsequent economic dislocation, was to cause a most cruel reappearance of what was called "scientific anti-Semitism" by the Nazis.

Despite its commitment to practice tolerance, the UN General Assembly did not recognize anti-semitism as a form of discrimination until December 1998, namely a half-century after the Holocaust. Within the the UN Commission on Human Rights in 1991 Jews were accused of murdering children to extract their blood to make ritual Passover food, and in 1997 Israel was accused there of infecting Palestinian children with HIV-contaminated blood.

Incidence:
Since the attempt by the Nazis to eliminate European Jewry, the burden of guilt and the fear of being associated with the views which led to that catastrophe have been a potent force in European politics, leading in several countries to legislation against the incitement to racial hatred and internationally inclining the countries of western Europe and the USA, towards the side of Israel. A 1992 report by the Anti-Defamation League shows one in five adult Americans (approximately 35-40 million people) holding severely prejudicial impressions of Jews, the greatest of which were expressed by citizens over the age of 65 who held at most a highschool diploma and were blue-collar employees. The 1992 report also found 31% of those questioned felt the Jewish community have too much power in the USA, while 35% believed Jews are more loyal to Israel than to America. According to the report of 1,400 people, there was little difference in the propensity for anti-Semitic views between religious groups and those not affiliated. Despite the astounding statistics, anti-Semitic sentiment in America has been slowly decreasing over the last 28 years. Antisemitism is still a potent force in east European political life and, under the guise of hostility to Zionism, in Arab states.

There is a sharp difference in anti-Jewish sentiment between east and west Europe. As a result of detailed surveys in 1991 in the former communist bloc countries, it is know that 61% of those questioned in the former Soviet Union are positively disposed towards Jews as compared to 18% in Austria. Majorities of Czechs, Slovaks, Hungarians and 44% of Poles view Jews as integral members of society, whereas one-third of Austrians believe that Jews are disliked generally and 19% want no Jews in their country. While 20% of East Germans took the view that Jew are overinfluential, the figure for West Germans was 44%. A 1992 poll of 3,000 Germans reported that 10% of West and 4% of East Germans wholly agreed with the statement : "It's the Jews' own fault that they have been persecuted so often in their history". A further 28 and 27%, respectively, found "a bit of truth" in the statement. Similar surveys in 1982 and 1987 found even higher degrees of anti-Semitism in West Germany. In 1992, 61% of French believed anti-semitism had grown in France in the past decade.

Claim:
Black anti-semitism is the only form of licensed anti-semitism in the USA, and the version of Jewish history presented by black teachers in American universities would make the Protocols of the Elders of Zion read like a eulogy.
Counter Claim:
Any intentional or unintended criticism of Israel, Judaism or Jews is called antisemitic. Jewish national emotions permeate the cultural life of whole countries. They are a negative influence on disarmament negotiations, on trade agreements and on international scientific and cultural relations. They provoke demonstrations and strikes. The Jewish issue acquires an incomprehensible power over people's minds, overshadowing the problems of other minorities.
Strategies:
Zionism
Problem Type:
D: Detailed problems
Date of last update
02.12.2017 – 12:48 CET